History of Quaker views on same-sex relationships
It is the nature and quality of a relationship that matters… the same criteria seem to us to apply whether a relationship is heterosexual or homosexual.- Towards a Quaker view of sex, 1963
In 1963, the booklet Towards a Quaker view of sex stated, "It is the nature and quality of a relationship that matters… the same criteria seem to us to apply whether a relationship is heterosexual or homosexual."
In 1988 Meeting for Sufferings, then our national executive body, recognised same-sex relationships and suggested that individual meetings might celebrate them.
Following the 2004 Civil Partnership Act, which permitted the civil registration of same-sex relationships, many Friends began to express unease. The ability of Quakers to recognise marriage in a religious context was excluded from the terms of civil partnership. The issue was then considered at various levels of our Yearly Meeting over several years.
After consulting all British Quaker meetings in 2007 the group appointed to review current opinion reported, "There is overwhelming evidence that attitudes have changed significantly in recent years, even since our current book of discipline [Quaker faith & practice] was published in 1995."
In 2008 Meeting for Sufferings recommended that the Yearly Meeting, "consider how we should celebrate and recognise committed relationships within our Quaker community and what revisions to Quaker faith & practice would follow from this to include same-sex partnerships."
Celebrating committed relationships
One of the subjects considered at Yearly Meeting in 2009 was our continued concern to celebrate committed relationships. Many spoke of their experience in the life of Quaker meetings saying that the gift of marriage was already being given to same-sex couples as well as opposite-sex couples. This led us to a profound compulsion to act. Yearly Meeting decided to seek a change in the law so that same-sex marriages could be held in Quaker meeting houses in the same manner as opposite-sex marriages, and that they would be recognised as equally legally valid.
This culminated in the extensive campaign work of Quakers and other faith groups until the Marriage (Same Sex Couples) Act was passed in 2013 and the Marriage and Civil Partnership (Scotland) Act in 2014.
Quaker marriage is for members and those who, while not in formal membership, are in unity with the religious nature and witness of Quakers in Britain. A Quaker marriage takes place during a specially arranged meeting for worship. The couple take each other as partners in a lifelong commitment to faithfulness and love. Each makes the same promise, seeking divine assistance to fulfil it.
There has been a period when Friends held a Quaker marriage that could not be reported to the state as a marriage but which was reported as a civil partnership. We recognise all Quaker marriages held since Yearly Meeting 2009 as equal, whether recorded by the state as a civil partnership or a marriage.
Same-sex couples who are civil partners and wish subsequently to convert this to a marriage in a Quaker meeting for worship may do so where this is permitted by law.
Comment on same-sex relationships
For the right joining in marriage is the work of the Lord only... we are but witnesses.- George Fox, 1669
Today we are amazed that 200 years ago people did not see that the practice of slavery was an injustice to our fellow human beings. We believe that 200 years from now people will be equally astounded to discover that in the twenty-first century many did not recognise the full equality of lesbian and gay people.
Photo credit: Wedding photo of Sally and Rachel Xerri-Brooks by Hannah Eno